An initiative of Atlanta Israel Coalition
Finding the Joy, a Kosher Duck Revolution column

When the Sun Set Early

Uriel ben Avraham
Uriel ben Avraham
November 19, 2026

On Tuesday we had a class at shul on the Amidah, the standing prayer at the center of every service. We talked about where it came from. We talked about Hannah, and the priest who decided she was drunk. And we talked about the difference between a prayer somebody wrote for you and one you make up yourself, and about the written one as an appointment with a friend. Even when you aren’t feeling it, you keep it, and keeping it reminds you.

Hannah first, because she’s the reason the Amidah sounds the way it does. At the start of the Book of Shmuel she can’t have a child, and she goes up to the sanctuary at Shiloh to pray. The verse says she “was praying in her heart; only her lips moved, but her voice could not be heard.” The priest Eli, sitting by the doorpost, watches her mouth working with no sound coming out and tells her to sober up.

The rabbis built the rules out of that scene. In the Talmud, Rav Hamnuna takes the verse a phrase at a time. She prayed in her heart, so you pay attention to what you’re saying. Her lips moved, so you actually say the words. Her voice couldn’t be heard, so the Amidah is said under your breath. And Eli thought she was drunk, so a drunk doesn’t pray.

Anyone who stands and mouths the Amidah is praying the way Hannah did on the day a priest took her for a drunk.

Where it came from is a longer argument, and the Talmud gives two answers side by side. Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi says the daily prayers stand in for the Temple’s daily offerings. Rabbi Yosei, son of Rabbi Chanina, says the patriarchs started them. Avraham, the morning prayer. Yitzchak, the afternoon. Yaakov, the evening, and Yaakov’s is this week.

Vayetzei opens with him on the road, running from a brother who wants him dead, and when night comes:

וַיִּפְגַּ֨ע בַּמָּק֜וֹם וַיָּ֤לֶן שָׁם֙ כִּי־בָ֣א הַשֶּׁ֔מֶשׁ וַיִּקַּח֙ מֵאַבְנֵ֣י הַמָּק֔וֹם וַיָּ֖שֶׂם מְרַֽאֲשֹׁתָ֑יו וַיִּשְׁכַּ֖ב בַּמָּק֥וֹם הַהֽוּא׃

He came upon a certain place and stopped there for the night, for the sun had set. Taking one of the stones of that place, he put it under his head and lay down in that place.

— Bereshit 28:11

“Came upon” is vayifga, the word for running into something. Rashi says our rabbis read it as prayer, the way GOD tells Yirmiyahu al tifga bi, don’t plead with Me, “and we learned that he instituted the evening prayer.” Rashi also notices that the sun doesn’t simply set. It sets suddenly, before its time, so that Yaakov has to stop where he is.

So by the rabbis’ reading, the first evening prayer belongs to a man who hadn’t planned on stopping, caught out by a sunset that came early.

It’s also the one prayer the rabbis couldn’t agree was required. The Mishnah says the evening prayer has no fixed time, and you can say it any time all night. The Gemara asks what “no fixed time” means and gets an argument. Rabban Gamliel says the evening prayer is obligatory. Rabbi Yehoshua says it’s optional. Generations later Abaye and Rava are still split. If you go with the offerings, that makes sense. The morning and afternoon prayers match the two daily offerings, and at night there was nothing new on the altar, just what was left from the afternoon, burning down until morning.

The Rambam rules that the evening prayer isn’t an obligation the way the morning and afternoon prayers are. “And even so,” he writes, all Israel, wherever they live, took up praying it anyway and accepted it as an obligation.

On his ruling, nobody had to. Everybody showed up anyway.

The Rambam also has the history behind the class’s other question, the written prayer versus your own. Prayer itself is a commandment from the Torah, he says, and for a long time it had no script. From Moshe to Ezra, people made up their prayers as they went, as well as they could and as often as they wanted. Then came the exile to Babylon. Children grew up speaking a little of everything, and when they went to pray they couldn’t get through a thought in Hebrew without other languages crowding in. So Ezra and his court set down eighteen blessings: praise at the start, thanks at the end, and in the middle the things everybody needs. The point, the Rambam says, was that the prayer of someone who can’t find the words would be as complete as the prayer of the most eloquent.

The script didn’t push out what you’d say on your own. Personal requests have a place inside the Amidah, in the blessing for the One who listens to prayer, and once you’ve finished it, the Gemara says, there’s no limit. Add as much as you like, even something as long as the Yom Kippur confession.

Yaakov does both, one night apart. That evening, if you follow the rabbis, he prays the evening prayer. The next morning he says something nobody wrote for him:

וַיִּדַּ֥ר יַעֲקֹ֖ב נֶ֣דֶר לֵאמֹ֑ר אִם־יִהְיֶ֨ה אֱלֹהִ֜ים עִמָּדִ֗י וּשְׁמָרַ֙נִי֙ בַּדֶּ֤רֶךְ הַזֶּה֙ אֲשֶׁ֣ר אָנֹכִ֣י הוֹלֵ֔ךְ וְנָֽתַן־לִ֥י לֶ֛חֶם לֶאֱכֹ֖ל וּבֶ֥גֶד לִלְבֹּֽשׁ׃

Jacob then made a vow, saying, “If God remains with me, protecting me on this journey that I am making, and giving me bread to eat and clothing to wear,

— Bereshit 28:20

It runs into the next verse: and if I come back safe to my father’s house, the ETERNAL shall be my God. It’s a list of conditions, and a short one. God with him on the road, bread, clothes, and getting home. It’s what a man says when he’s far from home and has just woken up with a stone under his head.

Hannah’s story has an ending the rules leave out. Once she told Eli she’d been pouring out her heart and not drinking, he sent her off in peace and asked the God of Israel to give her what she’d prayed for. Then she went and ate, the verse says, “and was no longer downcast.”

She didn’t have a child yet. Nothing she’d asked for had happened. She’d just said it.

Shabbat shalom.

— Uriel ben Avraham

← All Finding the Joy columnsFound a Duck? Add It to the Map →

Kosher Duck Revolution is an initiative of AIC. Join AIC. Membership starts at $9 a month.

Try

↑↓ to move↵ to openesc to close